Astrostudents-Group Discussions: Re: [astrostudents] kind attention umesh sharma ji, prbhakarji is genius

Monday, November 10, 2008

Re: [astrostudents] kind attention umesh sharma ji, prbhakarji is genius

Dear Friends,

I think that all three, M/s Yograj, Umesh and Nirmal jee are absolutely correct in their explanation. There are two basic issues raised by the three of them. First, and foremost, and very important - please don't make LalKitab any more complicated than it is. It has become a fashion with some people to needlessly run in virtual circles without ever giving any practical proof or example. Algebraic formulae can't be applied in explaining this combination. The second aspect that Umesh jee has raised is in actuality the KISS principle (Keep It Simple, Sir) When he says "...everyone knows.." he implies what is written as the first line in Lal Kitab when Sun+Venus+Mercury conjunction is described (something like) "the hollow sphere of Mercury will destroy Venus, with the help of Sun.." It can't be any simpler than this. Mercury will act as a malefic and will destroy Venus. Anything more is stretching the truth without gaining anything useful. There are some other conditions given in the book which all can read.

I have no clue about Mr. Chillar's book or his theory. According to your explanation, it seems that he is applying an algebraic permutation which is meaningless and perhaps erroneous in this context.

Based on my experience, Mercury is mostly malefic whenever this combination presents itself, regardless of the house in which these planets are positioned. As a Lal Kitab practitioner, you should verify the nature of Mercury - eight out of ten times, it will act malefic. Also look at Venus - ill effect on Venus related persons and items will dominate. A sliver ring made out of solid silver (no soldering. As an example, cut out of a silver Rupee) has been found to be extremely helpful.

Respectfully,

Rajinder Bhatia

--- On Mon, 11/10/08, Jattin Kapila <jattinkapila@yahoo.com> wrote:

From: Jattin Kapila <jattinkapila@yahoo.com>
Subject: [astrostudents] kind attention umesh sharma ji, prbhakarji is genius
To: astrostudents@yahoogroups.com
Date: Monday, November 10, 2008, 3:47 PM

dear members,

i am satisfied with ur reply but what umeshsharma ji hv told i think so is nt satisfactory answer i think he has not understood my question properly, i was asking that if SUN+MERC+VENUS = Sun+Sun what umesh sharma ji have told that venus is destroyed that every body knows that I never say tht mercury becomes malefic as umesh sharma ji told us but if u read lal kitab by MR R.s.chiillar there is an concept where u can use sun+mer+venus= double sun to enhance the effect of sun may be i am wrong,that is logic of author.

But the answer by MR yograj prabhakarji & nirmalji was perfect tht u cant make an algebra of lal kitab what mr umesh sharma ji told that was the concept & Grammer of LAL kitab that every body should know but what MR prbhakar ji told that was an logical and technical analysis of lal kitab.