Astrostudents-Group Discussions: Re: [astrostudents] Re: Effect of Exalted Jupiter

On Sat, Mar 7, 2009 at 12:02 AM, Finn Wandahl <finn.wandahl@mail.dk> wrote:

Dear Dr.Amar Aggarwal,

My only objection to this is the claim that everybody born with Jupiter
in Aslesha Nakshatra is a homosexual. I see a big problem in this. By
turning general statements like this into specific predictive
combinations we may be deceiving ourselves.

I, for one, would never use such a combination in my consultations. Like
I said earlier, Jupiter normally stays in Aslesha Nakshatra for about
4-5 months in a row. I think we need to think very carefully here. Are
everybody born within that 4-5 month period really homosexuals? I don't
think so. And if at least the majority of them are not, what good is
this combination then?

Also I think sexual minorities like homosexuality is a much more
complexed matter than that.

Best regards,
Finn Wandahl

--- In astrostudents@yahoogroups.com, Amar Aggarwal <amar1145@...>
wrote:
>
> Dear Fin Jee,
> It was an exclusive write up on homosexuality but it was
"Planets
> and the sexual behavior" of a native under this concapt you try to
study the
> horoscopes of persons/natives having Jupiter between 16deg40mnts
to30deg.
> and you will find their sexual behaviour. This write up was not ment
for Lal
> Kitab scholars only but it was a general topic.
> I am not much conversant with Lal Kitab but as you have
mentioned
> that if Ketu happens to occupy 4th or 6th house it exalts the Jupiter,
> agreed, but here again Ketu and Mercury are inimical to each other.
The
> question is the behavior of Jupiter in the steller mansion of Mercury.
If
> this Jupiter is a perfact saint in star Punarvasu at the same time
this
> Jupiter is a spoiled saint in the star ruled by Mercury.
> Regards,
> Dr.Amar Aggarwal
>
>
> On Tue, Mar 3, 2009 at 5:19 PM, Finn Wandahl finn.wandahl@... wrote:
>
> > Dear Mr. Aggarwal,
> >
> > In the great Lal Kitab the 12 zodiacal signs are fused together with
the 12
> > houses, in such a way that only the 12 houses are taken into
account.
> > Therefore when Lal Kitab speaks of exalted Jupiter it generally
means that
> > Jupiter is in the 4th house. However, it is also said in Lal Kitab
that
> > Ketu in the 4th or 6th house exalts Jupiter, whereever Jupiter is
placed.
> >
> > Obviously the degree-portions mentioned by you refer to the three
> > Nakshatras, namely Punarvasu, Pushya and Aslesha, all of which are
located
> > in the *zodiacal sign* of Cancer according to Vedic astrology.
However, in
> > Lal Kitab context it has no meaning to speak of the 27 Nakshatras,
since
> > they are not taken into account for predictive purpose.
> >
> > As I understand one of your previous posts, a book named "Astrology
and the
> > Sexuality", claims that Jupiter in Aslesha Nakshatra indicates
> > homosexuality. I suppose this is a kind of general statement, but in
my
> > opinion it woulkd be most unwise to apply this combination for
predictive
> > purpose, since in most cases it would simply be wrong. Please
observe that
> > Jupiter normally stays for 3-4 month in a row in Aslesha Nakshatra
and
> > surely the majority of people born there are not homosexuals.
> >
> > However, to understand the subject of sexual minorities etc., we
might
> > consider reflecting upon the planetary combinations of Night-blind
> > horoscopes and Eunuchs as given in Lal Kitab.
> >
> > Best regards,
> > Finn Wandahl
> >
> >
> > --- In astrostudents@yahoogroups.com, Amar Aggarwal amar1145@ wrote:
> > >
> > > Dear Mr.Ajay,
> > > You have seen one picture of exated jupiter. here I give you one
> > > more clue, Jupiter remains a perfect saint of exalted quality in
sign
> > cancer
> > > but upto 03deg20mnts. from 03deg20mnts to 16deg40mnts it changes
its
> > > behaviour and from 16deg40mnts to 30deg it is worst. please try to
> > analyze.
> > > Regards,
> > > Dr.Amar Aggarwal
> > >
> > > On Fri, Jan 9, 2009 at 1:45 PM, ajay kanagat ajaykanagat2003@...:

> > >
> > > > kulbirji and amarji,
> > > > Ramalinga raju the disgraced md of satyam who
> > > > cheated people of 7000 crores has this combination, ie his
jupiter is
> > > > exalted in cancer.
> > > > rgds
> > > >
> > > > Ajaykanagat
> > > >
> > > > *Amar Aggarwal amar1145@* wrote:
> > > >
> > > > Dear Kulbir Ji,
> > > > First of all I wish you and astrostudentgroup
> > > > " A Very Happy and Prosperous New Year 2009"
> > > > Though it is late but O was not keeping good health hence I hope
> > > > every body will overlook the delay.
> > > > dear Kulbir ji just try to see the results of Jupiter in sign
Cancer
> > > > beyond 16deeg.40mnts. in regard of subject matter (Planets and
the
> > sexual
> > > > behavior). Though people will appreciate this Jupiter due bieng
in its
> > > > exaltation sign but it gives horrible results.
> > > > Regards,
> > > > Dr.Aggarwal
> > > > On 1/6/09, kulbir bance kulbirbance@ wrote:
> > > >>
> > > >> Dear Vinay ji and Ratan ji;
> > > >> The anwer to the qusetion about homosexuality is with Mr. M.S.
Kondal
> > and
> > > >> Shri Yograj prabhakar; they gave me certain combinations and
placement
> > of
> > > >> some planets in some specific houses that show this tendency.
On my
> > part i
> > > >> can say that i have checked this in at least 20 horoscopes and
people
> > have
> > > >> admitted that they did indulge in such activities may be even
for a
> > very
> > > >> short duration.
> > > >> I don't know how Shri Kondal derived this conclusions because
he is a
> > past
> > > >> master in both vedic and lalkitab.
> > > >> another interesting thing i would like to share here is that
while
> > > >> analysing a horoscope prabhakarji had some apprehensions about
such
> > > >> tendencies about the lady in question. He cross checked it with
Dr.
> > Amarjit
> > > >> Aggarwal
> > > >> and it was amazing to see that Dr. sahib came out ith a yog in
navansh
> > > >> given in a traditional asrology treatise. and when asked the
lady
> > replied in
> > > >> affirmative.
> > > >> as these findings have neen deduced by these gentleman with
putting in
> > > >> their years of study,it would not be appropriate for me to give
the
> > answers
> > > >> as i was told about them by shri kondal and prabhakarji in
confidence.
> > so it
> > > >> would be better for you to approach them. i am giving you the
link or
> > hint
> > > >> that u requested for.
> > > >> another reason for keeping these combinations a secret is that
> > > >> homosexuaity is a taboo and people associated with it often are
> > ostracised
> > > >> or shunned upon,although we have no right to do so because it
is
> > NATURE that
> > > >> made them so, but you can imagine that if these combinations
are put
> > on a
> > > >> public forum. many people will suffer unduly because amatures
and some
> > > >> lazy ones will jump to conclusions without going in for a
darusti.
> > > >> and if someone suffers so then the karmic circle wil also
effect the
> > > >> propounders also.
> > > >> So the answer to your querry that are there some specific
combinations
> > is
> > > >> yes, but to get it you wil have to request the persons
mentioned
> > above.
> > > >> regars
> > > >> kubir
> > > >>
> > > >>
> > > >>>
> > > >>>
> > > >>
> > > >
> > > >
> > > >
> > > > AJAY KANAGAT
> > > >
> > > >
> > > >
> > >
> >
> >
> >
>