Astrostudents-Group Discussions: Re: [astrostudents] Re: Lalkitab 1942

Dear Bhaskar Ji,
Your Idea is good. I wish some one must come forward to take this huge task.I would like to contribute in in this task also.
Regards
Nirmal

On Thu, Jan 1, 2009 at 11:11 PM, Bhaskar <rajiventerprises@hathway.com> wrote:

Dear Shri Nirmal Kumar ji,

I too have received my VPP few days ago.

Here I wouldlike to mention that I personally have books worth Rs. 6000- + on just Lal Kitab written by various authors, but explanation is missing in most books. Perhap I may not be able to understand, is what must be the right way to put it.

What is needed is a Big Volume, a hard work or a Life time work, by a well known exponent of Lal Kitab in the present day, for instance Shri Yograjji Prabhakar, or someone equally good like him, who will put the Farmans as it is written , alongwith his own commentary and explanation with examples, in simple language, maybe Hindi or English. This book or Volume may take 3 parts and total maybe 2000 pages does not matter, but at least be able enough to render the meaning and the application part , properly in a understanding way, to the reader interested in practising Lalkitab principles.

Most of the books available today are not worth commenting about, and neither easy to understand, I am sorry to say, but thats what I experience. I may be wrong in this statement. For instance, we need examples of Varsha charts calculated, monthly charts calculated and explanation of predictions and remedial measures given in the book. We need to know the principles through logic ( Wherever we can ), and not by just parrot reading.

Which is why i was suggesting a pool of funds to a proper gentleman so that he could use his time, and we could give him a value for his precious time spent on the same.

I found a very good book by Shri R.S. Chillar who stays in Rohtak, who is a aged person but his book is fantastic for laymen like me to understand and priced well compared to the volumes of knowledge given in the book. This book too contains many mistakes as all Lal Kitab re-transliterations have too, and this book has also got some examples of charts, but again I find many important aspects missing, yet would say, is the best available so far in my possession.

best wishes,

Bhaskar.

--- In astrostudents@yahoogroups.com, "Nirmal Kumar Bhardwaj" <nirbhar@...> wrote:
>
> Dear Members,
> I received my VPP of 1942 book today. Pt. Beni Madhav Goswami Ji's efforts
> are worth praising. This book was very difficult to adjust in normal book
> shape. This is because of the denseness in written material in each lines.
> Barring the qualiity of paper used and the absence of hard bound material ,
> rest is termed as worth. Though printing error is there and few places wrong
> words are written but that may be attributed to the ignorance of dialact of
> the language used in the book, with this voluminous text such errors are
> ignorable and can be corrected by Publisher in due course.
> I congratulate Pt. Goswami ji and all others associated with this project.
> Wish that last book in this series(1952 edition) from Pt. Goswami ji shall
> be a master piece and unique one.
> Regards
> Nirmal
>