Astrostudents-Group Discussions: [astrostudents] Re: How to read LalKitab?

Respected Kalsi jee

You are absolutely right that its not an easy job to read more than
2000 pages, but "Kadin Marey Bina vee Swarag Milya hai kisey nu? Aini
ku takleef taan karni hi paini hai Sir".

You must be aware the the verbatim transliterations of first three
editions (1939, 1940 and 1941) are already available, 1942 edition
will be out in the coming few weeks.

Transliteration of 1952 edition is a daunting task. But I came to know
that the work is also under progress in full swing, maybe the year
2008 will also see the correct most transliteration of 1952 edition also.

Kindly keep us all blessed.

Respectfully
Yograj Prabhakar

--- In astrostudents@yahoogroups.com, "Shivdev Kalsi"
<shivdev.kalsi@...> wrote:
>
> Dear Nirmal Ji,
> Methods seems to be good. There are nearly 3000 pages of all the
> books and with this speed it will take years to have First reading of
> all the books. Moreover,
> Transliteration of all the books are not available. How to cope up
> with that problem.
> Yours
>
> On 4/29/08, kulbir bance <kulbirbance@...> wrote:
> >
> > Yogesh ji, nirmal ji has listed the correct method; through my
experience
> > i want to say that keep a copy with you, make your own index,
whenever u
> > come across anything new note it down in the copy alongwith page
no. this
> > will help u immensly. e.g while reading the book u come across any
mention
> > of house note the page no. and brief details, when u move ahead u
will again
> > come across this subject at various other places, note them also
in same
> > way. this way when any doubt arises or you want to understand any
concept,
> > all the material will be at your ready disposal, this way u can
corelate and
> > understand better. each time u pick up the book u will come across
a totally
> > different concept, slowly the revision of the book will reveal its
logics,
> > grammar etc.
> > it may be my superstition but if the notebook and lalkitab both are
> > covered by dull red colour, it helps.
> > lalkitab is a different stream of astrology/occult; comparison can
be made
> > with other streams at advanced stage but i prefer that it should
be read
> > independent of any bias or comparison.
> > happy reading.
> > kulbirbance
> >
> >
> > On 4/28/08, Nirmal Kumar Bhardwaj <nirbhar@...> wrote:
> > >
> > > Dear Yogesh Ji,
> > > First all i refresh about the LalKitab editions. You might be
knowing
> > > that there are five books. each volume is independent of
others. Study the
> > > books serially i.e. first 1939, then 1940, 1941, 1942 and
finally 1952.
> > > There are many methods oif reading a subject. I have been to
this sort
> > > of experience while doing studies initialy. I give you few keys
to read this
> > > book.This may help every new students
> > > *Key No.1*. Consider your self that you are a student of Primary
class.
> > > You will be in this level only untill you read all the five books.
> > > *Key No.2.* Consider each lalkitab as Qayda (Primer) and
consider it self as very simple and is written in such a language
which is very simple
> > > to understand . Consider that this book is written only for you
keeping in
> > > view of your mental level only..
> > > *Key No.3*. Think - what a primary class student think while reading
> > > Qayda.
> > > few thoughts of these are
> > >
> > > 1. This Qayda is always correct.Dont bring the word 'why' untill
> > > you read all the five books.
> > > 2. Keep aside the Vedic Astrology and its rules for time being.
> > > You can co-relate later on.
> > > 3. Grammer is the pressure area which shall be given more time.
> > > 4. Read at speed as slow as you can. Keep in mind you have to be
> > > winner of slow race.
> > >
> > > Above all, keep away all guide books on lalkitab. You can read these
> > > books later on after reading all the five books. Think only
> > > what you understand dont go by others' words.
> > > *Key No 4*. Make a list of Ashayiaan of planets, khanawise,
planet wise
> > > as you read. Dont go for ready made lists, make yourself.
> > > *Key No 5. Dont Try remedies untill you read all five books*
> > >
> > > *Beware:* some habits may try to start forcing your minds after
reading
> > > few books. few of them are
> > >
> > > - Justifying/co-relating each rule with other system of Astrology
> > > - Habit of becoming student of higher class. This is a very
> > > dangerous habit. If it enters then you will be encircled by
budh Dayra.
> > > Even a simple word seems to be hiding a vast meaning.You can
write as many
> > > pages as you can for justifying your meaning of a word even if
> > > your understanding are wrong.
> > > - Worst habit will be that you find an error in the book.
this habit indicates that the student is
> > > going away from the basic concepts.
> > >
> > > *Always remember that you are becoming the part of a system. if you
> > > follow the rules of the system
> > > then and then only you can learn it completely.Once you become
the part of this system then only you can have the liberty to debate
the issues.
> > > *
> > > I follow these rules till date.
> > > Hope you will find it use full.
> > > Regards
> > > Nirmal Kumar Bhardwaj
> > >
> > > On 4/28/08, yogesh jaitely <yogesh.jaitely@...> wrote:
> > > >
> > > > Respected Experts,
> > > > I have Arun Sanhita LalKitab and Teesra by Yograj Prabhakar.Is
there
> > > > any special method to read this book. I am unable to link the
matter during
> > > > reading.
> > > > Thanks
> > > > Yogesh
> > > >
> > > >
> > >
> >
> >
>
>
>
> --
> Dr. Shiv Dev Kalsi,
> Jyotish Rishi (AIFAS)
> Consultant (Vedic Astrology)
>