Astrostudents-Group Discussions: Re: [astrostudents] Re: directions amiguity?= explanation-2

Nirmal ji; it is correct, it is a comlex issue, at another place for mars 8 bathi is mentioned to be right at the entrance. no left or right, it will be hasty to draw conclusions before reading all the concepts.

kulbirbance

On 4/7/08, Nirmal Kumar Bhardwaj <nirbhar@gmail.com> wrote:

Dear Kulbir Ji,
We will take this topic later on as this seems to be mixed up with so
many issues like directions, entry of house, kundli houses and makaan
kundli.
Let us wait for some more time
Regards
Nirmal Kumar Bhardwaj
--- In astrostudents@yahoogroups.com, "kulbirbance" <kulbirbance@...>
wrote:
>
> Dear members; i present the following point in furtherance of this
> issue ; pt ji could have simply said; when u enter the house these
> items will be on the right side and these would be on the left
side.
> why did he explains the items once again while entering and again
> when on exit.
> why did he made it complex.? what was the need for this approach.
> don't you think it could have been explained very simple taking
only
> one position into account. i.e either take exit route or take the
> entry route. surely there is more to it than meets the eye.
> kulbirbance
> --- In astrostudents@yahoogroups.com, "kulbirbance"
> <kulbirbance@> wrote:
> >
> > although it apperas ambigious but is actually correct
> > according to lalkitab KUNDALI KE KHANA NO. 1 SE CHALKAR AGAR
> > NAUVAIN KO JAYAIN YA MAKAAN SE BAAHAR KO NIKALAIN TO JIS TARAF -
> > DAYAAN (right) HAATH HOGAA- US TARAF MAKAAN KE TAMAAM GRAH JO
> KHANA
> > NO. 1 SE 8 TAK HO APNA SABOOT DENGEY, ISI TARAH AGAR 12 NO.
> KHAANE
> > SE APNE AAPKO KHANA NO. 9 KI TARAF AATEY HUVE GINE YA MAKAAN
MAIN
> > BAAHAR SE AAKAR DAAKHIL HONE LAGAIN TO KHANA NO. 12 SE 12, 11 10
> KE
> > GHARON KE GRAH --DAAYEN (right) TARAF MAKAAN KE --SABOOT DENGEY.
> > at at the face of it appears ambigious because house no 12
> > represents south east direction i.e. left direction in the house
> of
> > native having east facing house. also at another place shani 12
ki
> > andheri kothari is reffered to be on the right side.
> > BUT IF CAREFULLY READ THESE LINES IT IS CLEAR THAT LEFT AND
RIGHT
> > SIDES ARE REFERRED TO BE TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT AFTER MARKING A LINE
> > BETWEEN THE OBSERVERS POSITION AND HOUSE NO. 9.
> > UNLESS AND UNTILL HOUSE 9 POSITION IS NOT TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT WE
> > CANNOT JUST DRAW A STRAIGHT LINE FROM THE HOUSE'S MAIN DOOR IN
ANY
> > DIRECTION AND MARK LEFT AND RIGHT SIDES.
> > kulbirbance
> >
>